TensorFlow, why was python the chosen language?
I recently started studying deep learning and other ML techniques, and I started searching for frameworks that simplify the process of build a net and training it, then I found TensorFlow, having little experience in the field, for me, it seems that speed is a big factor for making a big ML system even more if working with deep learning, so why python was chosen by Google to make TensorFlow? Wouldn't it be better to make it over an language that can be compiled and not interpreted?
What are the advantages of using Python over a language like C++ for machine learning?
The most important thing to realize about TensorFlow is that, for the most part, the core is not written in Python : It's written in a combination of highly-optimized C++ and CUDA (Nvidia's language for programming GPUs). Much of that happens, in turn, by using Eigen (a high-performance C++ and CUDA numerical library) and NVidia's cuDNN (a very optimized DNN library for NVidia GPUs, for functions such as convolutions).
The model for TensorFlow is that the programmer uses "some language" (most likely Python!) to express the model. This model, written in the TensorFlow constructs such as:
h1 = tf.nn.relu(tf.matmul(l1, W1) + b1) h2 = ...
is not actually executed when the Python is run. Instead, what's actually created is a dataflow graph that says to take particular inputs, apply particular operations, supply the results as the inputs to other operations, and so on. This model is executed by fast C++ code, and for the most part, the data going between operations is never copied back to the Python code.
Then the programmer "drives" the execution of this model by pulling on nodes -- for training, usually in Python, and for serving, sometimes in Python and sometimes in raw C++:
This one Python (or C++ function call) uses either an in-process call to C++ or an RPC for the distributed version to call into the C++ TensorFlow server to tell it to execute, and then copies back the results.
So, with that said, let's re-phrase the question: Why did TensorFlow choose Python as the first well-supported language for expressing and controlling the training of models?
The answer to that is simple: Python is probably the most comfortable language for a large range of data scientists and machine learning experts that's also that easy to integrate and have control a C++ backend, while also being general, widely-used both inside and outside of Google, and open source. Given that with the basic model of TensorFlow, the performance of Python isn't that important, it was a natural fit. It's also a huge plus that NumPy makes it easy to do pre-processing in Python -- also with high performance -- before feeding it in to TensorFlow for the truly CPU-heavy things.
There's also a bunch of complexity in expressing the model that isn't used when executing it -- shape inference (e.g., if you do matmul(A, B), what is the shape of the resulting data?) and automatic gradient computation. It turns out to have been nice to be able to express those in Python, though I think in the long term they'll probably move to the C++ backend to make adding other languages easier.
(The hope, of course, is to support other languages in the future for creating and expressing models. It's already quite straightforward to run inference using several other languages -- C++ works now, someone from Facebook contributed Go bindings that we're reviewing now, etc.)
★ Back to homepage or read more recommendations: